Seven cases, written for postgraduates and practising clinicians. Read the presentation, decide on stage, workup and plan, then open the line of management. No doses are given; durations follow the evidence.
A 34-year-old teacher has had fatigue for a year and was treated with iron tablets twice for haemoglobin of 8 g/dL with low ferritin. Her stools are normal. Her father had “intestinal cancer” at 48 and her aunt had uterine cancer at 50.
Before you open the answer: what is the stage, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Investigate the anaemia
Iron deficiency without an obvious cause needs both endoscopies, even at 34. Colonoscopy: ulcerated caecal cancer; biopsy adenocarcinoma, poorly differentiated with tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes.
- Stage and test
CT chest-abdomen-pelvis: no metastases. CEA normal. MMR immunohistochemistry: loss of MSH2 and MSH6 — Lynch syndrome likely.
- Surgery
Lynch syndrome is suspected before surgery, so total colectomy with ileorectal anastomosis is offered to cut the roughly 20% 10-year risk of a new colon cancer after segmental resection; she chooses it after discussing bowel function. 31 nodes, 3 positive (pT3 N1b).
- Adjuvant therapy
Stage III dMMR: FOLFOX with atezolizumab for 6 months where available (ATOMIC); otherwise CAPOX or FOLFOX.
- Germline and family
Germline MSH2 pathogenic variant confirmed. Yearly endoscopy of the remaining rectum; upper endoscopy from 30–35 with H. pylori treatment; yearly urinalysis (MSH2 carries urothelial risk); risk-reducing hysterectomy and salpingo-oophorectomy after childbearing; daily aspirin. Cascade testing offered to siblings and children (from 18–20).
Teaching points
- Anaemia in a young adult with low ferritin is a gut question, not a dietary one.
- MMR status changes adjuvant therapy, the extent of surgery and the family’s screening.
- MSH2/MSH6 loss is not explained by MLH1 methylation: go straight to germline testing.
See: Sections 02, 04, 06 · Algorithm 1 · ATOMIC[40], CAPP2[2], Parry 2011[75]
A 72-year-old man presents with 4 days of absolute constipation, colicky pain and a distended abdomen. He was treated for “gas” and “piles” over the past 3 months.
Before you open the answer: what is the stage, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Resuscitate and image
Drip and suck; contrast CT: obstructing sigmoid tumour, dilated colon with a caecum of 9 cm, no perforation, no metastases.
- Choose the operation
Options: emergency resection (Hartmann’s, or primary anastomosis ± covering stoma), or a self-expanding stent as a bridge to elective laparoscopic surgery in 1–2 weeks in an experienced centre. He had a stent, recovered, completed staging and colonoscopy, and had an elective sigmoid colectomy.
- Pathology
pT4a N0, 16 nodes, pMMR, no lymphovascular invasion. Obstruction and T4 are both high-risk features.
- Adjuvant therapy
High-risk stage II: 3 months of CAPOX, or a fluoropyrimidine alone given his age and neuropathy from diabetes; absolute benefit is modest and is discussed with him.
- Follow-up
CEA and CT for 5 years; colonoscopy at 1 year; exercise programme.
Teaching points
- Emergency presentation is common and carries worse survival; earlier colonoscopy would have helped.
- Stent as a bridge allows staging and elective surgery but needs expertise.
- Stage II benefit from chemotherapy is small: risk features and fitness decide.
See: Sections 02, 03, 05, 06 · Algorithm 1 · IDEA[38], QUASAR[39]
Case 3Rectum · high risk · TNTA 52-year-old with “piles” and a threatened margin
52 years, mancT3c N2 EMVI+, CRM 0.5 mmMid rectum, 7 cm
A 52-year-old shopkeeper has bled per rectum for 8 months and was treated with piles ointments. He now has tenesmus and has lost 5 kg. A finger reaches a hard, fixed lesion at the tips.
Before you open the answer: what is the stage, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Diagnose
Proctoscopy and colonoscopy: mid-rectal adenocarcinoma; pMMR. CEA 12.
- MRI pelvis
Lower edge 7 cm from the anal verge; cT3c, tumour 0.5 mm from the mesorectal fascia (threatened CRM), EMVI positive, 5 mesorectal nodes (N2), lateral nodes not enlarged.
- Distant staging
CT chest-abdomen-pelvis: no metastases.
- Total neoadjuvant therapy
Short-course RT followed by about 18 weeks of CAPOX (RAPIDO), or induction mFOLFIRINOX then chemoradiation (PRODIGE 23) given his fitness. Fertility counselling and sperm banking first.
- Reassess and operate
MRI and endoscopy after TNT: good partial response, CRM now clear. Laparoscopic low anterior resection with TME and a temporary loop ileostomy; ypT2 N0, complete mesorectum. Ileostomy reversal at 3 months.
- After surgery
No further chemotherapy (all given before surgery). Follow-up CEA, CT and pelvic MRI as scheduled; LARS advice and pelvic floor exercises.
Teaching points
- Persistent bleeding despite piles treatment demands a rectal examination and endoscopy.
- Threatened CRM, EMVI and N2 define high-risk disease: TNT is preferred.
- Fertility counselling must precede pelvic radiotherapy.
See: Sections 03, 05, 06 · Algorithm 2 · RAPIDO[47], PRODIGE 23[48]
A 61-year-old retired nurse has a low rectal cancer 4 cm from the anal verge. Surgery would need an ultralow anterior resection with likely poor function, or an abdominoperineal resection. She asks whether there is any way to avoid a stoma.
Before you open the answer: what is the stage, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Stage
MRI: cT2 N1, CRM clear, no EMVI, sphincter not involved. CT: no metastases. pMMR.
- Organ-preservation plan
Long-course chemoradiation followed by consolidation chemotherapy (OPRA approach), aiming for a clinical complete response.
- Response assessment
At 8–12 weeks: flat white scar on endoscopy, no palpable tumour, no residual tumour signal on MRI — a clinical complete response.
- Watch-and-wait
Digital examination, endoscopy and MRI every 3–4 months for 2 years, then every 6 months; CEA and CT as usual.
- If regrowth
About a quarter regrow, mostly within 2 years; salvage TME is usually possible. She understands and accepts the surveillance.
Teaching points
- Organ preservation is an evidence-based option for selected low tumours.
- Strict surveillance is the price of keeping the rectum.
- Discuss bowel, sexual and urinary function, not only survival.
See: Sections 05, 06, 08 · Algorithm 2 · OPRA[49], International Watch & Wait Database[24]
A 29-year-old software engineer has rectal bleeding. Biopsy shows a mid-rectal adenocarcinoma. The pathology report includes MMR immunohistochemistry: MLH1 and PMS2 are lost. He is booked for chemoradiation the following week.
Before you open the answer: what is the stage, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Pause
dMMR changes the plan. BRAF V600E is negative and MLH1 promoter methylation is absent: germline testing (likely Lynch).
- Stage
MRI pelvis cT3 N1, CRM clear; CT no metastases.
- Treatment
Anti-PD-1 therapy alone (dostarlimab or another anti-PD-1, in a trial or expert setting) for 6 months, with MRI and endoscopy every 2–3 months; chemoradiation and surgery are held in reserve for non-response.
- Outcome
Clinical complete response at 6 months; watch-and-wait surveillance. Fertility, function and work are preserved.
- Family
Germline MLH1 variant: cascade testing, colonoscopy for relatives.
Teaching points
- Know the MMR status before planning radiotherapy.
- dMMR rectal cancer responds poorly to chemotherapy but very well to immunotherapy.
- Young age plus dMMR: germline testing is mandatory.
See: Sections 04, 06 · Algorithm 2 · Cercek 2022[51], NICHE-2[46]
Case 6Metastatic · liver-only · conversionSix liver metastases in a 55-year-old
55 years, manSigmoid primary, 6 liver lesionsRAS/BRAF wild-type, pMMR, HER2-negative
A 55-year-old accountant has a sigmoid cancer with six liver metastases in both lobes, the largest 6 cm near the right hepatic vein. CT chest is clear. He is fit (ECOG 0).
Before you open the answer: what is the stage, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- MDT with a liver surgeon
Not resectable now: the remnant would be too small. Potentially resectable if the tumours shrink.
- Conversion therapy
Left-sided, RAS/BRAF wild-type: FOLFOX (or FOLFIRI) with panitumumab or cetuximab for the highest response rate.
- Restage every 2–3 months
After 4 months: 60% shrinkage; now resectable with a two-stage approach (left lateral clearance, portal vein embolisation, then right hepatectomy).
- Surgery
Liver resections and sigmoid colectomy in staged procedures; R0. Ablation for a small residual lesion.
- After
Complete about 6 months of perioperative chemotherapy in total; CEA and CT every 3–4 months; about 4 in 10 such patients are alive at 5 years, though most relapse at some point.
Teaching points
- Show liver metastases to a hepatobiliary surgeon before chemotherapy.
- Choose the most active regimen for the biomarkers when conversion is the goal.
- Operate as soon as resectable: “vanishing” lesions and chemotherapy liver injury complicate late surgery.
See: Sections 05, 06 · Algorithm 3 · PARADIGM[18], EPOC[25]
Case 7Metastatic · BRAF V600EAscites and right-sided cancer in a 47-year-old
47 years, womanAscending colon, peritoneal + liverBRAF V600E, pMMR
A 47-year-old homemaker presents with abdominal distension and weight loss. CT shows an ascending colon mass, omental cake, ascites and three liver metastases. Biopsy: adenocarcinoma.
Before you open the answer: what is the stage, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Biomarkers first
NGS: BRAF V600E, RAS wild-type, pMMR, HER2-negative. DPYD normal. ECOG 1.
- First line
Encorafenib + cetuximab + mFOLFOX6 (BREAKWATER) where accessible; otherwise FOLFOXIRI + bevacizumab if fit, or FOLFOX + bevacizumab. Anti-EGFR alone with chemotherapy is ineffective in BRAF-mutant disease.
- Supportive
Early palliative care; nutrition; drainage of ascites as needed; watch for bowel obstruction from peritoneal disease.
- Second line
If not given first: encorafenib + cetuximab (BEACON). Later: trifluridine–tipiracil + bevacizumab, regorafenib or fruquintinib; clinical trials.
- Goals
Discuss prognosis honestly: BRAF V600E disease progresses fast, but targeted combinations have substantially improved survival.
Teaching points
- Test BRAF at diagnosis of metastatic disease: it changes first-line therapy.
- Right-sided, peritoneal and BRAF often go together.
- Plan supportive and palliative care from the start.
See: Sections 04, 06 · Algorithm 3 · BREAKWATER[13], BEACON[14]