Eight cases, written for postgraduates and practising clinicians. Read the presentation, decide on diagnosis, workup and plan, then open the line of management. No doses are given.
Case 1Oral tongue · early · DOIA tongue ulcer treated with gels for three months
46 years, manLateral tongue, 1.8 cmcN0, DOI ~4 mm on MRI
A 46-year-old shopkeeper who chews gutka has a painful ulcer on the left lateral tongue next to a sharp molar. Two dentists prescribed gels and smoothed the tooth; it persisted for 3 months. Examination: 1.8 cm indurated ulcer, no palpable nodes. Punch biopsy: moderately differentiated SCC.
Before you open the answer: what is the likely diagnosis, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Staging
MRI of the oral cavity and neck: DOI about 4 mm, no suspicious nodes; CT chest clear. Dental review; tobacco cessation.
- Surgery
Partial glossectomy with a 1 cm planned margin and an ipsilateral selective neck dissection (levels I–IV), because DOI is above 3 mm.
- Pathology
pT2 (DOI 6 mm), margins clear at 7 mm, 0 of 28 nodes, no PNI or LVI: stage II.
- After surgery
No adjuvant therapy. Follow-up 1–3-monthly in year 1; stop gutka permanently (the field is at risk).
Teaching points
- Two weeks is the limit for an unexplained mouth ulcer: biopsy.
- DOI, not size alone, drives T stage and elective neck treatment.
- Elective neck dissection improved survival in early oral cancer (D'Cruz).
See: Sections 02, 03, 05 · Algorithm 1 · D'Cruz 2015 [38], Senti-MERORL[39]
A 52-year-old agricultural worker who has used khaini and pan for 30 years has a 3.5 cm ulceroproliferative lesion of the right buccal mucosa. Mouth opening is two fingers (submucous fibrosis). A 1.5 cm mobile level IB node is palpable. Biopsy: SCC.
Before you open the answer: what is the likely diagnosis, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Staging
Contrast CT face and neck: no bone invasion, no masticator space involvement; one 1.6 cm level IB node without ENE. CT chest clear. Dental clearance; dietitian.
- Surgery
Wide excision with a margin of the buccal pad and skin preserved, modified neck dissection, radial forearm free flap to reline the cheek.
- Pathology
pT3 (DOI 11 mm), margins clear (6 mm), 1 of 32 nodes positive (2 cm, ENE negative), PNI present.
- Adjuvant
Postoperative RT (about 60 Gy) to the primary and neck, starting within 6 weeks; no chemotherapy (no positive margin or ENE). Jaw-stretch exercises during and after RT to prevent trismus.
Teaching points
- Buccal cancers spread deep early; reconstruct the lining or trismus follows.
- Adjuvant RT alone for intermediate-risk features; cisplatin only for margins or ENE.
- Submucous fibrosis makes examination and follow-up harder: train the patient in self-examination.
See: Sections 02, 05, 06 · Algorithm 1 · Bernier 2005 [62], Ang 2001[48]
Case 3Gingivobuccal T4a · CPS ≥1 · ENEA loose tooth that was extracted
58 years, manLower gum, bone invasioncN2b, CPS 15
A 58-year-old man had a loose lower molar extracted; the socket never healed and a growth appeared. Examination: 4 cm lesion of the lower gingivobuccal sulcus with chin numbness and two palpable ipsilateral nodes. Biopsy: SCC; PD-L1 CPS 15.
Before you open the answer: what is the likely diagnosis, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Staging
CT: erosion into the medullary mandible (T4a), two nodes (N2b). PET-CT: no distant spread. Stage IVA. Fit, PS 1.
- Options at the tumour board
Surgery first, or two doses of neoadjuvant pembrolizumab followed by surgery and pembrolizumab with and after adjuvant RT (KEYNOTE-689, CPS ≥1). Cost and access discussed; he chooses the pembrolizumab route through an assistance programme.
- Surgery
Composite resection with segmental mandibulectomy, comprehensive ipsilateral neck dissection, fibula free flap with plate.
- Pathology
pT4a, margins clear, 3 nodes positive, one with extranodal extension.
- Adjuvant
RT with cisplatin (ENE) plus pembrolizumab, then maintenance pembrolizumab. (Had he not received neoadjuvant pembrolizumab, nivolumab with cisplatin-RT would be the NIVOPOSTOP option for this HPV-negative, ENE-positive disease.)
Teaching points
- A non-healing extraction socket is a classic presentation of gingival cancer.
- Bone invasion → segmental resection and free-flap reconstruction.
- ENE → chemoradiation; checkpoint inhibitors now extend the options before or after surgery.
See: Sections 04–06 · Algorithm 1 · KEYNOTE-689 [1], NIVOPOSTOP [2], EORTC 22931[28]
A 44-year-old software engineer notices a painless, soft 3 cm lump below the right angle of the jaw, treated as a branchial cyst. FNAC: squamous carcinoma, p16 strongly positive. Examination: small firm area in the right tonsil.
Before you open the answer: what is the likely diagnosis, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Staging
PET-CT: 1.5 cm right tonsil primary, one cystic ipsilateral node (2.8 cm), nothing else. HPV-associated cT1 N1 = AJCC 8th stage I. HPV DNA confirmed.
- Options
Definitive RT alone (a single node ≤3 cm; chemotherapy is added for larger or multiple nodes in many guidelines) or transoral robotic surgery with neck dissection, choosing the route least likely to need a second modality. ORATOR showed similar swallowing outcomes.
- If chemoradiation is chosen
Cisplatin, not cetuximab: cetuximab gave worse survival in RTOG 1016 and De-ESCALaTE.
- Follow-up
PET-CT at 12 weeks after RT; examination schedule; smoking advice for life; partners do not need special testing.
Teaching points
- A cystic neck mass in an adult is a metastasis until proven otherwise.
- HPV-associated cancer has its own staging and a better prognosis.
- Do not de-escalate outside trials.
See: Sections 02–04 · Algorithm 2 · Ang 2010 [20], RTOG 1016 [23], ORATOR[21]
A 63-year-old auto driver has been hoarse for 2 months after a cold; two courses of antibiotics did not help. Flexible laryngoscopy: an irregular lesion on the middle third of the left vocal cord, both cords mobile. Biopsy: SCC.
Before you open the answer: what is the likely diagnosis, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Staging
CT neck: no cartilage invasion, no nodes. T1a N0, stage I. Chest CT: emphysema, no lesion.
- Options
Transoral laser cordectomy or small-field RT (slightly hypofractionated). Both give high local control and similar voice; no elective neck treatment.
- Plan
He chooses RT to avoid anaesthesia. Smoking cessation started before treatment (continued smoking lowers control).
- Follow-up
Laryngoscopy every 1–3 months in year 1; yearly low-dose chest CT (heavy smoker); recurrence after RT → salvage surgery.
Teaching points
- Hoarseness >3 weeks in a smoker = laryngoscopy.
- Early glottic cancer rarely spreads to nodes: treat the cord only.
- Smoking cessation is part of treatment and prevents second lung cancers.
See: Sections 02, 05 · Algorithms 2 and 3 · MARCH[46]
A 57-year-old teacher has hoarseness, pain on swallowing and a left earache. Laryngoscopy: supraglottic tumour extending to the glottis with a fixed left cord. CT: paraglottic spread, no cartilage destruction; one 2.5 cm ipsilateral node. Biopsy: SCC. He wants to keep his voice.
Before you open the answer: what is the likely diagnosis, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Staging
T3 N1, stage III. PET-CT: no distant disease. Creatinine clearance 85 mL/min, normal audiogram, PS 0.
- Larynx preservation
Cisplatin chemoradiation with IMRT to the larynx and both necks (RTOG 91-11), or TPF induction then RT in responders. Laryngectomy with adjuvant RT remains an equal-survival alternative.
- Supportive care
Swallow exercises from week 1, dietitian, dental review; feeding tube if weight falls.
- Response
PET-CT at 12 weeks: complete response. If residual disease had been found, salvage laryngectomy would be the next step.
Teaching points
- T3 larynx can often be preserved without losing survival.
- T4a with cartilage destruction does better with laryngectomy.
- Salvage surgery must be available before choosing organ preservation.
See: Sections 05–06 · Algorithms 2 and 3 · VA Larynx [40], RTOG 91-11 [41], TAX 324[53]
A 71-year-old retired farmer has dysphagia and 9 kg weight loss. Endoscopy: right pyriform sinus tumour. CT: T3 N2b. Creatinine clearance 42 mL/min; uses a hearing aid. PS 1. Biopsy: SCC, p16 negative.
Before you open the answer: what is the likely diagnosis, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Nutrition first
Dietitian; nasogastric or gastrostomy feeding before treatment; dental review.
- Sensitiser
Cisplatin is contraindicated (kidney function, hearing). Options: RT with weekly low-dose docetaxel (Tata trial: 2- year OS 51 vs 42%) or carboplatin-based chemoradiation; RT alone if frailty increases. Cetuximab is a weaker choice.
- Radiotherapy
IMRT, once daily, no gaps; weekly review of weight, mucositis and pain.
- After treatment
PET-CT at 12 weeks; swallow rehabilitation; TSH monitoring; goals-of-care discussion given the high distant risk of hypopharyngeal cancer.
Teaching points
- Age alone does not decide, but chemotherapy adds little over 70: weigh fitness carefully.
- Weekly docetaxel is an evidence-based, affordable sensitiser when cisplatin is impossible.
- Hypopharyngeal cancer presents late and malnourished: feed before you treat.
See: Sections 06, 08 · Algorithms 2 and 4 · Patil 2023 [26], MACH-NC 2021[22]
Eight months after surgery and adjuvant cisplatin-RT for an oral tongue cancer, a 60-year-old man has cough. CT: multiple lung nodules; biopsy confirms metastatic SCC (rather than a new lung primary). PD-L1 CPS 25. PS 1. Family income is limited.
Before you open the answer: what is the likely diagnosis, what must be done before treatment, and what is the plan?
Show the line of management
- Is it curable?
Multiple lung metastases: no; aim for longer life with good quality.
- Best evidence
Pembrolizumab alone (CPS ≥20: median OS 15 vs 11 months over EXTREME, with far less toxicity); add chemotherapy if symptoms progress fast.
- If full-dose immunotherapy is unaffordable
Low-dose nivolumab with oral metronomic chemotherapy (Tata Memorial trial, improved survival), or metronomic chemotherapy alone; EXTREME-type chemotherapy if fit.
- Palliative care
Introduced at the same visit: symptom control, home care, and discussion of goals with the family.
Teaching points
- Biopsy a new lung lesion: second primary or metastasis changes treatment.
- CPS decides first-line immunotherapy.
- Evidence-based, lower-cost options exist and should be offered openly.
See: Sections 06, 07 · Algorithm 5 · KEYNOTE-048 [3], Patil 2023 [70], Patil 2019[69]